Short Story Review: "Chip" by Jon Edwards

A Chip Off the Old Block: A Review of a Cautionary Tale

Title: Chip
Author: Jon Edwards (The Mind's Attic)
Publication date: 12 November 2024
Format: Short Story of 3492 words
Source: https://jtewriting.substack.com/p/chip

In the not-so-distant future, the lines between reality and virtual reality are becoming increasingly blurred. The latest technological advancements have made it possible for people to upgrade their minds with brain implants, allowing them to access a world of information and entertainment at the mere thought of it. But what happens when this technology becomes mandatory, and individuals are forced to conform to societal norms in order to fit in? This is the question that Jon Edwards' dystopian short story, "Chip," seeks to answer.

Through the eyes of Calvin Thompson, a young man who is resistant to the idea of getting a brain implant, we are taken on a journey into a world where technology has become the ultimate controller. As Calvin navigates the complexities of his new reality, he begins to realize that the benefits of the chip come with a steep price: his autonomy, his freedom, and his very sense of self. This story explores the consequences of a society that values technology above all else, and the impact it has on the human experience.

In this review, we'll delve into some of the story’s themes and ideas and examine the ways it challenges our assumptions about the role of technology in our lives. We'll also take a look at the characters and their motivations, and explore the ways in which the story raises important questions about the future of humanity.

Spoilers ahead.

The Illusion of Control

In "Chip," Edwards explores the theme of control in a way that's both thought-provoking and unsettling. The brain implant, touted as a revolutionary tool for self-improvement, slowly reveals its true nature: a means of control that erodes individual autonomy.

The corporation's influence is everywhere, dictating what information is available and what thoughts are allowed. Calvin's struggles with the chip are a perfect example of this. He resists the idea of getting the implant, but ultimately is forced to conform. Once he has the chip, he's bombarded with messages and information that he can't escape.

This theme is particularly relevant in today's world, where technology is increasingly integrated into our daily lives. We're constantly being bombarded with information, and it's easy to feel like we're losing control. Edwards' story is a warning about the dangers of relying too heavily on technology and the importance of maintaining our autonomy.

The character of Mr. Harrison is another great example of this theme. He's a master manipulator, using his power to control and influence those around him:

“Sir, with all due respect, I am simply not quite comfortable with it,” I said. He stood from his chair and walked behind me. I stood to meet him and he opened the door for me to exit. 

“I understand Calvin, I do. But these, right here?” He said, tapping, the door frame. “These begin to close. And they stay closed. Double bolted. Locked down. Don’t you want to see the company succeed? Don’t you want to be part of Harrison Advertising history? Part of the legacy?”

This reminds us of the concept of the "culture industry", developed by philosophers Theodor Adorno and Max Horkheimer. The culture industry refers to the way in which modern capitalist societies use mass media and technology to shape our desires and values, creating a culture that is designed to keep us in line. In the context of "Chip," the corporation's use of the brain implant as a tool of control can be seen as a form of culture industry, where individuals are shaped and controlled by the corporation's programming. The chip is not just a tool, but a means of creating a culture that is conducive to the corporation's interests.

By exploring the theme of control through the lens of the culture industry, the story highlights the dangers of unchecked technological advancement and the importance of maintaining our autonomy.

The Loss of Autonomy

In "Chip", individuals are forced to conform to the expectations of others. In other words, they have lost their autonomy. This theme is particularly relevant in today's world, where technology is increasingly being used to monitor and control people's behavior.

A real-life example of this is the Chinese government's use of facial recognition technology to monitor and control its citizens. The technology is used to track people's movements, monitor their behavior, and even predict their actions.

Similarly, the use of social media algorithms to manipulate people's behavior is another example of the loss of autonomy. These algorithms are designed to keep people engaged and active on social media, often at the expense of their mental and emotional well-being.

Calvin's loss of autonomy is a powerful symbol of the dangers of surrendering our freedom to the whims of others. He is a man who is desperate to break free from the corporation's control, but is unable to do so. The implications are profound. If we are no longer in control of our own lives, then what does that mean for our humanity? Are we still individuals, or are we just cogs in a much larger machine? These are questions that "Chip" raises, but doesn't necessarily answer.

The Commodification of Data

Another unsettling aspect of "Chip" is the way it portrays the commodification of personal data.

The corporation that created the chip is not just interested in providing a useful tool, but in harvesting and selling the data that flows through it. This is a theme that is all too relevant in today's world, where our personal data is being bought and sold like a commodity. Take the character of the man who appears to Calvin, offering him a "premium" service. He is a shady figure, using high-pressure sales tactics to get Calvin to upgrade his chip and provide more data. But what's really going on is that he's trying to get Calvin to give up even more control over his personal data, so that it can be sold to the highest bidder.

The data collection process is also interesting. The chip is not just collecting data, but is actively manipulating Calvin's thoughts and feelings to get him to provide more information. This is a commentary on the way that many modern technologies, from social media to online advertising, are designed to manipulate and influence our behavior. These techniques are sometimes collectively called "dark patterns".

The consequences of this commodification of data are also explored in the story. Calvin's data is used to manipulate him, to get him to do things that he doesn't want to do. And when he tries to resist, he is punished, forced to conform to the corporation's expectations. This is a warning about the dangers of allowing our personal data to be bought and sold, and the importance of protecting our autonomy and agency in the face of overwhelming external influences.

The Blurring of Reality and Virtual Reality

The brain implant, which is supposed to enhance Calvin's life, instead creates a sense of disorientation and confusion. The lines between what's real and what's virtual become increasingly blurred, and Calvin struggles to distinguish between the two.

This theme is reminiscent of other works of science fiction, such as Philip K. Dick's 1969 novel "Ubik", which also explores the idea of a world where reality is constantly shifting and uncertain. The 1999 movie "eXistenZ" by David Cronenberg also delves into the theme of virtual reality and its impact on our perceptions of reality.

The way Edwards portrays this blurring is rather scary. The virtual world, which is supposed to be a tool for Calvin's benefit, instead becomes a source of anxiety and fear. The characters that appear to him, like the man who offers him a "premium" service, are not just virtual entities, but seem to have a life of their own.

The implications of this blurring are profound. If the virtual world is indistinguishable from reality, then what does that mean for our understanding of the world? How can we trust our perceptions of reality if they can be manipulated by external forces? These are questions that the story raises, but doesn't necessarily answer. It's a clear warning, though, about the dangers of losing touch with reality and the importance of maintaining a connection to the physical world.

Conclusion

So, what's the takeaway from "Chip"? Well, for starters, it's a cautionary tale about the dangers of relying too heavily on technology. It's like that old saying goes: "Be careful what you wish for, because you might just get a brain implant that turns you into a corporate drone."

But in all seriousness, the story explores what happens in a society that values technology above all else. It's a reminder that our autonomy and individuality are precious, and that we must fight to protect them.

In the end, this is a short story that will leave you questioning the true cost of progress, and wondering what the future holds for humanity. And who knows, maybe it'll even inspire you to take a step back from your phone and enjoy the world around you. But before you do, you can find a link to "Chip" below.

P.Q. Rubin

---

Chip

---